The Quote That Lost Money: 3 Numbers Every Contractor Must Know Before Pricing a Job
He quoted $85 an hour for labour and believed he had priced in a profit. Then the three-day roofing job wrapped up, every invoice landed, and the real math surfaced: his true cost of doing that work was approximately $91 an hour. He had not made a thin profit. On a constructed, assumption-based estimate, he had effectively paid about $6 an hour for the privilege of climbing his own ladder.
Nothing went wrong on that roof. The shingles were fine. The crew was fine. What failed was the quote — because it was built on the only number he knew: the wage. A quote is not a guess with a dollar sign. It is three numbers, stacked in the right order. Miss any one of them, and you can work hard, work well, and still come home poorer than you left.
First, watch the story in a few minutes:
This video was created using ethical AI. It is for educational purposes only and is not tax or financial advice.
Now, the three numbers — in full.
Number 1: Your true labour cost
A wage is not a cost. It is the beginning of one.
On top of every dollar of wages sit the employer's own payroll obligations. Employer CPP contributions match the employee's contributions. Employer EI premiums are 1.4 times the employee's premiums. Add WCB premiums, vacation pay, and any benefits, and the loaded cost of an hour climbs well past the number on the paycheque.
How far past? It varies by trade, crew, and province, so treat this as an approximate, assumption-based range: for many Alberta trades, the burden adds roughly 25 to 33 percent on top of the wage. On a $38 wage, that puts the true labour cost at approximately $52 an hour — before the truck starts, before a single material is loaded.
This is the number that quietly killed the roofer's quote. He compared his $85 price against the $38 wage and saw room. His actual labour cost was already far closer to the price than he thought — and labour is only the first layer.
Quote from the wage, and you have lost money before the first shingle is lifted.
Number 2: Your overhead per billable day
The second number is the one most owners never calculate at all: what it costs to open the doors each working day, whether a quote covers it or not.
Vehicles. Insurance. Fuel. Phones. Software. The shop or yard. Add up a year of those fixed costs. As an illustration — approximate and assumption-based — say they come to about $62,000 a year.
Now divide. Not by 365 — you do not bill Christmas. Not by the days you hope to work, either. Divide by the days you actually bill: weather days, gap days between jobs, and callback days all come out. For many crews, that lands at roughly 200 billable days a year.
$62,000 over approximately 200 days is about $310 a day. That $310 is owed every single working day, job or no job. If a three-day quote does not carry roughly $930 of overhead inside it, the overhead does not disappear — it comes out of the profit. And when there is no profit, it comes out of you.
Number 3: A margin you choose on purpose
Most owners price like this: add up the costs, then put "a bit on top." That bit is whatever survives the job — a material overrun, one rain delay, one callback — and usually, nothing survives.
Margin works the other way around. You decide it first, as a deliberate number, and price to protect it. Fifteen percent is a common target; whatever figure you choose, choosing it is the point.
And understand what a discount really does. On a job priced with a 15 percent margin, giving 10 percent off the price does not trim 10 percent off your profit — it cuts that profit by roughly two-thirds. Discounts feel like generosity. On thin margins, they are a pay cut you volunteer for.
The stack, assembled
Put the three numbers together on the roofer's three-day job. All figures are approximate and assumption-based — a worked example, not a promise:
- Materials: $2,400
- Labour: 48 hours (two workers, three days) at the true cost of about $52 — $2,496
- Overhead: 3 days at about $310 — $930
- Subtotal: approximately $5,826
- Margin at 15 percent: the quote lands at approximately $6,700
His old way — 48 hours at a guessed $65 an hour, plus materials — produced $5,520. Same job. Same crew. Same roof. An approximate difference of $1,180, decided at the kitchen table before anyone climbed a ladder.
That is the whole game. Not working harder. Not finding cheaper shingles. Stacking three honest numbers in the right order before the price leaves your mouth.
This is our trade — so it does not have to be yours
Now, honestly: that is a lot of arithmetic to carry when your actual business is roofing. You are on a roof all day and quoting at night. The costing setup keeps sliding to next week, because next week is when the next roof is booked. That is normal, and it is not a character flaw — costing is simply not your trade.
It is ours. This baseline work — your true labour cost, your overhead per billable day, your margin — is exactly what we set up with owners, built once and built properly, so every quote after it takes minutes instead of evenings. If your prices are still built on a guess, that is the conversation to have with us.
Just starting out? Start with real numbers
And if you are new in business, this matters even more — new businesses are our first call for a reason. You have no last-year figures to lean on, so your baseline costs begin as assumptions. That is true of every forecast ever made, and there is no shame in it. The difference is whether those assumptions are guessed in a hurry or built carefully and accurately from the start.
We set new owners up from the very setup — labour cost, overhead, margin — so your first quotes already stand on real numbers, and the assumptions get trued up as your actuals come in. Starting right is far cheaper than repricing a year of underquoted work.
The bottom line
A quote is three numbers: what an hour of your crew truly costs, what a day of being in business truly costs, and a margin you chose on purpose. Know your three numbers before you quote, and the price takes care of itself.
Not sure what your three numbers are? Email us at talk2us@kaa-services.com — we will help you build your baseline.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not tax or financial advice.
#Plumbers #Electricians #Roofers #HVACTech #GeneralContractor #ContractorLife #SkilledTrades #Trades #TradesBusiness #Contractors #AlbertaContractors #ConstructionLife #TaxPlanning #Bookkeeping #Payroll #BusinessPlanning #BusinessAdvisory #TaxTips #Alberta #AlbertaBusiness #SmallBusinessCanada #AlbertaSmallBusiness #SmallBusinessTips #CanadianSmallBusiness #Calgary #YYC #Edmonton #YEG #RedDeer #Lethbridge #GrandePrairie #FortMcMurray #MedicineHat #Airdrie #StAlbert #SherwoodPark #SpruceGrove #Leduc #Okotoks #Cochrane #Brooks #Camrose #Lloydminster #Canmore #Banff




Comments