Everyone Is Talking About Canada's Economy. Why Does the Conversation Mostly Stop Before the Factory?
Canada's redevelopment begins with a 21st-century manufacturing revolution. Canadian products, Canadian workers, Canada's future.
Opinion — by Rajesh Sabharwal
November 4, 2026
One weekday evening, a woman stands before the tomatoes doing the arithmetic everyone now does. The ones grown here cost as much as 40 per cent more than the ones trucked in from Mexico and the United States. Given an equal choice she would reach for the Canadian ones — most of us would. But the choice is not equal, and the imported ones go into the cart. That distance is not her failure. It is a question our economy has stopped asking.
This piece proposes that Canada rebuild itself as a manufacturing economy — and asks why that proposal is so rarely looked at. In the conversation leading into this budget, our leaders' words were protect, support, modernize, diversify markets; the opposition's were save, sue, scrap, get a deal. No government minister, no opposition leader or member of Parliament, and no provincial leader set a target for manufacturing's share. At the margins, a few voices asked it — among them one economist and one columnist. I ask it here — without claiming the answer.
What we can see
Canada still makes a great deal; what shrank is the share — a fifth of the economy in 2000, a tenth today. Jobs went from 2.24 million to 1.85 million, and on the UN's industrial competitiveness ranking Canada fell from 5th to 22nd — the steepest fall among advanced economies. We diversify, mostly, by finding new customers for the same beginnings. Economist Jim Stanford said it plainly: "Canada is looking for new customers. It should be asking what it plans to sell them." Too often we sell the beginning of a chain and buy back its end — our lithium leaves; the batteries return.
Now the paradox: Canada is one of the United States' largest customers. We buy enormously from the country whose tariffs squeeze us, while so much of what is made here is made in plants that answer to boardrooms in other countries. The jobs are real; the workers are ordinary Canadians doing skilled, honest work. But when cuts come, the home plant is protected first. Work that exists at another country's pleasure — that will always be second-hand. As the Globe's Arthur Lam asked: what comes after the branch-plant economy? Again and again, what Canada invents here ends up owned elsewhere.
Conditions, not just cheques
After the Second World War, manufacturing stood near 30 per cent of our output. In 1965, the Auto Pact traded tariffs for guaranteed production here. Within four years, vehicle exports to the United States rose from 7 to 60 per cent of production, and auto became our largest industry. The lesson is structure, not nostalgia: access traded for production, here, by people here. When a later era's trade rules ended the pact, nothing replaced its logic — the stance changed, from conditions to cheques.
Arthur Lam, writing in the Globe and Mail, put the price of that change in one line: "Canadians will continue to depend on other countries for the privilege of earning a living in Canada."
The recent record shows the cost of cheques: the Parliamentary Budget Office counts more than $52 billion pledged over the past five years to the world's largest car and battery companies, and the promised return has not come in as sold — plants delayed, plans paused, value never arrived. What if even a tenth of it — some $5 billion — had been pledged to build makers here at home? Unconditional support fails. So the first move needs no new money — only conditions on the money already moving: investment matched to private commitment, tied to production, research and decisions here, paid against milestones, not announcements. Subsidies matter, and they may include tax subsidies; the instrument is for decision makers. We offer the destination: close the gap.
Today's help for the industries hit by tariffs should continue — and for the biggest of them it is mostly loans: a $10-billion loan facility for large employers, and $5 billion in export financing and insurance. A loan can bridge a company through a tariff shock. It cannot cure the dependence that made the shock dangerous. And alongside the help, a part of the money has to start the new makers. Manufacturing today gets help here and there — a BDC window, a program, a little movement — but no national strategy and no national focus. We gave artificial intelligence a national strategy, a minister of its own, and billions aimed at its young companies. Where is the same push for the Canadian who wants to start making things?
Three horizons, one destination
In the short term — one to two years — the question is a household one: what do Canadians get today? The short term is for healing: relief on the cost of living in Canada, shelf prices, the food-bank line. No factory can be promised inside two years, and none is promised here. In the mid term — inside five years — the manufacturing revolution is asked to land: finishing more of what we start, then climbing — our own finished goods, our own car, in time a sovereign nation's engines and aircraft. In the long term — beyond five years — come pipelines, trains, megaprojects. Self-sufficiency is not one road; it is a roundabout — many roads, one destination. Each horizon fuels the next — short-term goals fuel the mid term, whose rules grow into the long term.
Feed our own shelves first
The other half is us — and Canadians are already reaching: 65 per cent sought Canadian products in an October survey. But excitement is built by action and results on a shelf, not announcements. Look at food, where agriculture meets manufacturing: we grow the fruit and import the jam, the tomatoes and import the ketchup. Finishing our own food at home is the nearest part of the revolution. A grocer reorders what sells, a brand follows the shelf, a manufacturer follows the order. The country that makes the things Canadians buy holds the real power, and today that is often another country. Nobody should be lectured into paying 40 per cent more out of patriotism. The gap is the problem, never the shopper. Close the gap by making, and choosing Canadian becomes easy — and free.
Self-consuming, self-reliant, sovereign
The sequence: self-consuming first — a country that buys and uses what it makes; then self-reliance; then self-sufficiency. And the defence: self-consuming does not mean a closed country. Exports are part of this — simply not the first step — and we keep our allies and agreements. But dependence weakens a nation over the long term. The test is plain: if a crisis closed the import lines, could we still put food on the table? Feed our own shelves first; self-reliance and sovereignty follow — and self-reliant countries can export anywhere they choose. Sovereignty is bigger than a declaration: negotiated with allies, backed by our own independent manufacturing decisions — or the negotiation is only words. Prime Minister Mark Carney calls this "a rupture, not a transition," and says middle powers must build strength at home. What if we meant it — in the factory?
China, India, Malaysia and Indonesia climbed this ladder: making things was how a developing nation became a developed one. Which raises a thought, offered honestly — not as fact, but as a sketching point. What if we stopped calling ourselves a developed nation, finished and complete, and adopted the rules of a country redeveloping itself? In South Korea, manufacturing still makes up over a quarter of the economy; in Germany, close to a fifth. Redevelopment is not a step backward; it is how a country decides it is not finished.
Economics was once taught only in school, then belonged to degree-holders; today an enthusiast can study seriously and contribute without a university's permission. The discussion is open.
A challenge to the conversation
The food-bank story is prime — its figures lead: 2.35 million visits in one month — a record, up 117 per cent since 2019, almost one in five of them people who have a job. But it is reported as news, never as accountability. Once is a mistake. Twice may be an error. Three years of records, and we are not doing everything possible to get out of this crisis — and still the follow-up question is not asked. Prime time goes to the hype — elbows up, the 51st-state talk — while results must land within the lifetimes of people who will not be here for a twenty-year project. Politics empowers the media; the media empowers politics; between that loop and the safe lines of the experts, the conversation stops before the factory. Journalism has a sacred line between reporting and activism, crossed often enough that our media looks polarized — or is at least perceived that way. The media houses are businesses; profit is their business. But every journalist can ask one honest question inward: am I becoming what I really shouldn't be? Start these conversations. Help build the Canada of the 21st and 22nd centuries — the future.
And you, reading this: why are we not looking at this? Economist who disagrees — say why; who agrees — say that too. If you simply work and pay bills here, your answer counts as much as anyone's. The comments are open; if enough voices gather, we will gather them into a piece of their own.
This is where that conversation begins — it does not end here. There is more to say about a manufacturing revolution, and we mean to keep saying it. Canada has already opened one gate: we set out to build our own strength in artificial intelligence, with a national strategy behind it. If we can focus like that on artificial intelligence, we can focus like that on making things. The gate is open. What remains is to walk through it.
Return to the grocery store. Nothing here asks her to pay 40 per cent more out of patriotism. It asks whether Canada will do the deliberate work — conditions on our money, food finished at home, factories full of ordinary Canadians making real things — so that one day the two tomatoes stand at a fair price, side by side, and her choice is free. A country that makes what it needs feeds its people first — then it grows.
If we do not change how we do things, we will be changed by the changing environment around us.
A closing note: this is an opinion, and only a suggestion — not aimed at any person, body, organization or political party, and not intended to offend anybody. It is a thought-provoking question, asked in the open.
On how this piece was made: the thoughts and the first draft are my own. I am not an economist — I am an economics student and an avid economics enthusiast. It was put together with the help of ethical AI.
Made with Ethical AI
References
Statistics Canada — manufacturing share of GDP and output series (manufacturing near 30% of total output in 1961; ~20% of GDP in 2000 to ~10–11% today); Monthly Survey of Manufacturing, August 2026 (released October 15, 2026).
Jim Stanford, Centre for Future Work — manufacturing employment 2.24 million (2000) to 1.85 million (2025); machinery and equipment investment 6.3% to 3.2% of GDP; interview and chapter, October 15, 2026.
Globe and Mail, "Manufacturing descent: Canada's industrial comeback won't be easy," October 26, 2026 (National Bank economists) — UN Competitive Industrial Performance Index: Canada 5th (2000) to 22nd (2024).
S&P Global Canada Manufacturing PMI, November 2, 2026 — 49.6 in October, first contraction of 2026.
Arthur Lam, "The branch-plant economy is breaking in Canada. Now what?", Globe and Mail op-ed, October 27, 2026.
Post-war record — Statistics Canada historical series; RBC, Manufacturing Trends (2017); Bank of Canada, Stephen Poloz, "It takes a world to raise a nation" (2017): the 1965 Auto Pact's production guarantees; vehicles exported to the US from 7% of production (1964) to 60% (1968); Auto Pact expired February 19, 2001.
Parliamentary Budget Office — ~$52 billion+ in pledged EV/battery subsidies; plant delays and pauses as reported in the research record, October 2026.
Statistics Canada, table 12-10-0011 — US share of Canadian merchandise exports, 75.9% (2024) to 68.3% (12 months to August 2026); on the customer side, US Census Bureau figures put Canada second only to Mexico as a market for US goods exports (12 months to August 2026).
Narrative Research / Logit Group, Buying Canadian survey (September 21–28, 2026; released October 22, 2026) — 65% of Canadians sought out Canadian products.
World Bank — manufacturing value added, % of GDP: South Korea 27.4%, Germany 17.6%.
Food Banks Canada, HungerCount 2026, October 21, 2026 — 2.35 million visits in March 2026, a record; +117% vs 2019; 18% of clients employed.
Mark Carney, address to the World Economic Forum, Davos, January 20, 2026 — "We are in the midst of a rupture, not a transition"; middle powers and "build our strength at home."
Fen Osler Hampson (Carleton University) & Tim Sargent (Macdonald-Laurier Institute; University of Calgary School of Public Policy), "Globalization gutted Canada's manufacturing. Here's how we make things ourselves again," Globe and Mail, May 19, 2026 — "The policy response must be unapologetically ambitious."
Commission on Carbon Competitiveness & Transition Accelerator, The Right Move at the Right Time: A New Canadian Industrial Strategy, June 2025.
Robert D. Atkinson, Comfortable Decline: How Canada Chooses Stability Over Dynamic Prosperity, Centre for Canadian Innovation and Competitiveness / ITIF, May 2026 — Hamilton-industries share of the economy 10.1% (1995) to 6.9% (2022); Canadian productivity near 77% of US levels.
Réka Juhász (UBC), Nathan Lane (Oxford) & Dani Rodrik (Harvard), "The New Economics of Industrial Policy," Annual Review of Economics 16 (2024) — cited for the legitimacy of state-led production policy; Rodrik himself holds that manufacturing "is no longer a source of job creation," a limit this piece notes rather than hides.
Mariana Mazzucato, "Directing Growth: How a mission-oriented industrial strategy can help drive productivity," UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose, Working Paper 2025-06.
Bilge Erten, Joseph E. Stiglitz & Eric Verhoogen, "Employment Impacts of the CHIPS Act," Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Fall 2025.
Kari Levitt, Silent Surrender: The Multinational Corporation in Canada (1970; McGill-Queen's University Press, 2002).
The Economist, "Homeland Economics" special report, October 2023 — the counterview, included deliberately: it documents the global return of industrial policy in order to argue against it ("Governments across the world are rediscovering industrial policy. They are making a big mistake, argues Callum Williams.").


Comments