top of page

The $2,500 Payday Mistake: What One Late Payroll Remittance Really Costs

Oct 20
5 min read

An electrician finishes a panel in a basement renovation, coils his cable, and checks his phone. Payday. His crew's pay has landed — and so has his, because for a one-truck electrical shop, payday is the same day for everyone.


What he doesn't know yet: the money he was supposed to send the CRA for that pay run went out a week late. The penalty for those seven-plus days? Approximately twenty-five hundred dollars — not in wages, not in taxes he owed anyway. A charge for being late, on money that was never his to begin with


First, his day — and the mistake — in a few minutes of video:


This video was created using ethical AI. It is for educational purposes only and is not tax or financial advice.


Now the full story, because this is the most expensive simple mistake in small-business payroll.


The money was never yours

Every payday, an employer holds back amounts from the crew's paycheques — income tax, CPP, EI — and adds the employer's own share. Section 153 of the Income Tax Act requires those amounts to be remitted to the Receiver General. And section 227(4) goes further: the money is deemed to be held in trust for the Crown from the moment it is withheld.


Read that again, because it changes how the money feels. It is not the business's cash that happens to be earmarked for taxes. In law, it was never the business's money at all. Spending it on materials, or using it to bridge a slow-paying customer, is spending trust money — and delivering it late is what the penalty ladder below is built to punish.

The schedule is the CRA's, not yours


Later that week, our electrician is at the electrical supply house, pay stub in hand, stocking up on wire and breakers. What he has never quite pinned down is when his remittance is actually due — because the CRA assigns the schedule, based on how much an employer withholds. The Income Tax Regulations set it out:


- Monthly (Regulation 108(1)): most small employers. Pay your crew in October, and the remittance must reach the CRA by November 15.

- Quarterly (Regulation 108(1.12)): very small payrolls — average monthly withholding under $3,000, with a clean twelve-month record of remitting and filing on time — may be approved to remit quarterly, due April 15, July 15, October 15, and January 15.

- Accelerated, Threshold 1 (Regulation 108(1.1)(a)): as payroll grows, paydays before the 16th of the month come due by the 25th of the same month, and paydays after the 15th come due by the 10th of the next month. The largest payrolls remit within days.


One detail matters as much as the dates: the CRA must receive the money by the due date. The day it left your account is not the test.

The penalty ladder, exactly as the Act writes it


Back in his small office after hours, the wall calendar tells the story — payroll day circled, due date circled, and a week of daylight between when the money went and when it should have. Section 227(9) of the Act sets the price of that gap:


- 1 to 3 days late: 3%

- 4 to 5 days late: 5%

- 6 to 7 days late: 7%

- More than 7 days late, or no remittance at all: 10%


A worked example, approximate and assumption-based, using a typical crew payroll: a $25,000 remittance sent eight days late lands in the 10% band — approximately a $2,500 penalty. (Section 227(9.1) softens the edge slightly: the penalty applies only to the amount over $500.) On top of the penalty, interest is charged under section 227(9.2) and compounded daily. And a second failure in the same calendar year, if it was made knowingly or with gross negligence, doubles the rate to 20% — on the same numbers, approximately $5,000, for the same week of delay.


Three habits that keep you off the ladder


On the next payday, watch what changes. He runs payroll at his desk and moves the remittance the same sitting — because that is habit one: tie the remittance to payday, not month-end. The money moves the same week the crew is paid.


Habit two: the remittance amount goes into a separate account the moment payroll runs. If it is not sitting in the operating account, it cannot get spent on a supply run.


Habit three: keep the account clean. In a tight month, remit what you can, on time — interest alone is cheaper than interest plus penalties. And in a month with no payroll at all, tell the CRA the remittance is nil. That last point is the CRA's administrative expectation, not a duty written in the Act — but following it is what stops a failure-to-remit notice from landing on a business that owed nothing.


Rules change — and staying current is the employer's job


One more scene: a fresh notice in hand, he crosses out an old date on the office calendar and writes in the new one. Schedules, thresholds, and rates change, and “I didn't know” is not a defence. Staying current with the remittance rules sits with the employer — full stop.


That is exactly the watch we keep for the businesses we work with. If keeping up with the CRA's clock is one job too many on top of running yours, that is a conversation worth having with us — payroll runs on today's rules, not last year's, and we make sure of it before the calendar does it for you.


And if you are just starting out: new businesses are our first call, on purpose. Your first payroll sets the pattern — the right schedule, the money set aside from the very first payday. At the setup stage, some of your numbers are necessarily assumptions, as every forecast is; we build them accurately from the beginning and true them up as your actuals come in, so the CRA's clock never catches you learning.

The bottom line


The CRA doesn't charge you for the mistake. It charges you for the days. Payroll runs on the CRA's clock — and the businesses that respect that clock never meet the penalty ladder.


Know your dates before they cost you.


Not sure which schedule the CRA has you on — or whether last month's remittance landed on time? Email us at talk2us@kaa-services.com — we will walk through it with you.


This article is for educational purposes only and is not tax or financial advice.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page