Paying Your Helper Cash? What the CRA Actually Sees
Paying Your Helper Cash? What the CRA Actually Sees — full body text:
It's Friday afternoon. You've got a slab to pour, a furnace to swap, or three bathrooms to rough in, and your regular guy brought his cousin to help. At the end of the day you hand the kid a couple hundred in cash, he says thanks, and you both move on. No paperwork. No fuss.
If that sounds familiar, you're not alone — it's one of the most common arrangements in Alberta's home-service trades. And it's also one of the ones the CRA understands better than you'd hope.
Here's the part that surprises most contractors: paying in cash doesn't change what the payment is. The CRA doesn't look at how the money changed hands. It looks at the working relationship — who set the hours, who supplied the tools, who directed the work. If the person shows up where you tell them, when you tell them, using your tools, doing the work your way, the CRA sees an employee. The cash in the envelope doesn't register.
And once the CRA sees an employee, a whole set of obligations kicks in that nobody told you about at the supply house.
1. The withholdings you were supposed to make
When someone is your employee, you're not just paying them — you're the CRA's collection agent. Every paycheque is supposed to have three deductions taken off before the money reaches the worker's hands:
Income tax, based on their TD1 and the CRA's payroll tables
CPP contributions (both the employee's share and yours as the employer)
EI premiums (again, both shares — and the employer's share is the larger one)
Then those amounts have to be remitted to the CRA on a set schedule — monthly for most small employers, and the deadlines are strict.
Here's where the cash arrangement quietly turns expensive. When you hand someone $200 in cash, none of that happened. The CRA's position is simple: you still owed it. So in a review, they can assess you for the unremitted tax, the missing CPP and EI (both shares), plus interest from the day it was due, plus penalties for failing to deduct and remit. The penalties stack on top of amounts that were never that large to begin with — and interest in a CRA payroll review doesn't negotiate.
A "casual arrangement" that felt like it saved you paperwork can end up costing multiples of what proper payroll would have.
2. The T4 you never filed — and why it matters
Every employee needs a T4 slip at year end, and the CRA needs its copy too. Cash helpers almost never get one, because in most contractors' minds, "he was just helping out."
But the CRA's definition of employment doesn't have a "just helping out" exception. Part-time, seasonal, a few days a month, paid daily — casual and day labour still counts as employment income if the working relationship looks like employment. The number of hours doesn't flip a switch. Neither does calling someone a subcontractor while treating them like staff (that's a whole separate CRA test, and it's one contractors lose regularly).
Missing T4s are a red flag in themselves. When the CRA reviews a business and finds workers with no slips, no payroll account, and no remittances, it doesn't assume everything was fine. It reconstructs. And reconstruction is never generous — the CRA estimates what you should have withheld and remitted, and the burden shifts to you to prove them wrong. Without records, that's a fight you're bringing a handshake to.
HEADING: 3. No records means it's their word against yours
This is the one that actually keeps accountants up at night. Suppose a cash helper files for EI, or gets hurt on a job, or simply tells the CRA a different story about the arrangement than you do. What do you have?
No pay stubs. No timesheets. No signed agreements. No payroll register. Just your memory of what you paid and when — against a worker who may remember it differently, or a government agency with forms and procedures.
Proper payroll records protect you. Dated pay records, hours worked, amounts paid, deductions taken — they're your evidence that the arrangement was what you say it was. Without them, in any dispute, it's your word against theirs, and the CRA has a well-documented habit of picking a side. It isn't yours.
This isn't about distrusting your helper. It's about the fact that memories fade, people move on, and the CRA audits on paper, not on handshakes.
The fix is simpler than the problem
Here's the good news: setting this up properly is a one-time job, and then it mostly runs itself.
Open a CRA payroll account (it's an extension of your business number — takes minutes once you know where to click).
Put helpers on a real pay run — even a simple bi-weekly or monthly payroll with proper deductions. Payroll software does the math; you just confirm hours.
Remit on schedule and file the T4s every February. Done.
The cost of doing it right is a fraction of the cost of getting caught doing it wrong — and it buys you something cash never can: a paper trail that proves you're compliant.
Most Alberta contractors didn't get into the trades to become payroll experts. You got into it to build things, fix things, and run a business you're proud of. Payroll is one of those unglamorous foundations that either quietly supports the business or quietly sinks it. A ten-minute check of who's on your jobs and how they're paid is the cheapest insurance in your whole operation.
Got someone helping you on jobs and not sure where you stand? That's exactly the kind of thing we sort out every day.
Kaa-Services — bookkeeping, taxes & payroll, done for you, 100% online. For Alberta's plumbers, electricians, HVAC pros, contractors and roofers.
kaa-services.com | Bookkeeping from $300/mo | talk2us@kaa-services.com




Comments